Many gained land from their axis occupiers in World War 2.  The Dutch did not. So why?

A special thanks to my patrons below.

Jens Koch-Nommensen
Øystein Alsaker
Carl Österbrand
Sergio M. Vela
mamoun alnasr
Matthew Bakke
Heath Robertson
Dave Brondsema
Hasmuffin 
Michael Kram
Franco La Bruna
Bradley chaulk
Ethan 
Don Bonnigan
Azlow the Lion
Spencer W
Ian Whitcomb
Southside Mitch
John
Matthew Literovich
Ryan Schindeler
JakeBak0905
Ray Charles Barkley
Tom Ebert
Shion
S. Marisol Asselta
Aaron Conaway
DocOzz13 .
Philip Yip
Samantha O'Leary
Shauna K
Piotr Wojnowski
Steven Gibson
Phoenix Fats
Jane Sumpter
Joooooshhhhhh 
Vance Christiaanse
BeninPrince51
Mario Peshev
Travis Mount
Sean D.
Joshua Rackstraw
sharpie660
Andy McGehee
Christopher Godfrey
Ariel David Moya Sequeira
imperialgerman
Brooks Woolson
Phillip Gathright
Alex Teplyakov
Zhao Liu
Tony Belmonte
D. Mahlik
Arthur Hosey Jr.
Nicholas Menghini
Colonel Oneill
Baste 
Paul Munro
Joshua Schneider
Ron Johnson
Dr. Schtnizel
Porkmeister
AF FireFly
Jamie van Brewen
Roman Kynčl
Josh J
Shakira Graham
Jack Wicks
zockotron
Andrea Dekrout
Andreas Mosand
Jack Nelson
Konstantin Bredyuk
Nick Macarius
Andrew F
Windischgraetz
Barry
ConspiracyPizza 
Angel Aguiñaga
Thomas McGraw
William Swiacki
MGS2600
Ivaer 
Chris Winther
Jake Faust
Dana Spurgeon
Allen Rines
Nolan Peale
Jacob Zachs
GrokThis
Liam Gilleece
Contdoko12
Katie Flinn
John Garcia
HelloAgain
Mickey Landen
Andrew Patane
Tactical_Jackal 
Snowdon
Shawn Morse
Keith A. Layton
Sahni 
mgnesium.poetry
Carl Blanton
Ciege Engine
Sethars
Tiffany Twisted
Chase Labiste
Bradley Backoff
Matthew Toles
Michael Galloway
Chris Weisel
Zach Rust
Bret Allan
Bernice 
Vilena5
Harley Raptopoulos
Leena Al-Souki
Clayton Schuman
Dullis 
KNSTRKTVST
Matthew O'Connor
Brian George
Matthew Maguire
ARandomPaperClip
Wilhelm Screamer
Aaron Larrow
Serius_Loyola
William Adderholdt
Justin Short
Michael Myers
blaZzinG_FurY
Jason Gould
Ben Drums 24
LAMAR DANIEL-KELLY
Curt Helmerich
Bodo Nuber
Victor Gomez
TH
Hexapuma
Hudson Plaskoff
Ahmed Roshdi
Ryan Marinelli
Matt Reed
bas mensink
JAY ALAN EDELMAN
george tyler
Tim Stone
Ned Burke
Blue Cardinal
Abhijeeth 
Juan Castillo
Steve Bonds
Joel Cromwell
Clay Carroll
Thomas McGill
Steven Mastronardo
Toshnika
Anthony McCann
Ali Sadighian
Łukasz Burchard
Greyceful
Perry Gagne
Tyler Jenkins
BattleGoat Studios
Colm Byrne
Joseph Hutchins
Joseph Reinsch
Alen
Oliver Jenner
Dexter_McAaron
David van Reyk
Tim Sweeney
Bartosz Zasada
No way
Raymond He
Logical Insanity
Geoffrey Sparrow
Warren Rudkin
Christian Vasquez Leon
Liquid Chief
Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel
Andrew Niedbala
Yared Cristiano
kevinh
Emily D
Matt Busch
ThePalestRose
Burt Clothier
Chach
Vegard Tønnessen
Benjamin Bowring
SketerK
Bren Ehnebuske
Tim Stumbaugh
Matthew Ward
Alex Slepak
Ken Warner
Random Insanity
Ian Smith
Stefan Møller
Adam Rabung
Melissa Prober
Erik Hare
luvrhino
Peter Marino
Ryan Lowe
pdswanfleet 
Jonny Minogue
SirAlpaka 
Bernardo Cavalcanti
Zach Weakland
Emily Glover-Wilson
William Wilkerson
Andrey Listochkin
James 
Brian Giordano
Joseph Kerckhoff
Sterling Archer
Robin!
Käs
Nathan Ngumi
Mars Project
Azul Bravestrong
William Clark
Richard Wolfe
Yuichiro Kakutani
Thomas Wang
Rob Rollins
John Orr
Eric Askins
LambOfLeg 
Donald Weaver
Sara Birnbaum
David Spellmeyer
Ryan Haber
Yosef Waysman
Tristan Kreller
Joker 54
Manny F
Alexander Liu
Tino
Romney Manassa
anon
JT96
nullptr 
Scott Oppel
Michael Dierker
Sean Long
Chasen Le Hara
Gordon Wilson
Ball State
Gregory Priebe
Mirza Ahmed
Tranier Bocaj
Jeremiah Reidy
Pat Stahl
Joshua A Bishop
James R DeVries
Juan Benet
Ian M
Kevin Phoenix
Augustus Caesar
Kinfe85
Daniel D.
Ryan Krug
Mark Littlehale
Mr. Awesome
Igor Stavchanskiy
mohd 
Allen
Laurent Othacehe
Charles Doolittle
John Gross-Whitaker
Aiden Chappell
Alex G.
DHILON RAY
אורי פרקש
Wolf 
Anthony Uk
Jeffrey Schneider
Ellen Teapot
I'm Not In The Description
Michael Wagner
Austin Martin
Mik Scheper
Mark Ploegstra
Franklin Sousa
Dustin Koellhoffer
Roko Lisica
Colm Boyle
Jesse Plung
Phil and Lisa Toland
M.D. Villalobos
0_DannyBoy
FRANK A COBBINA
Douglas MacLean
Nathan Snyder
Robert Brockway
Miky Hidalgo Morriss
Dutchball Animations
Dr. Howard Dr. Fine Dr. Howard
Lech Duraj
Sophie Winter
Heytun 
George Caponera
Danny Anstess
Will Sullivan
Now Seibert 
Zachary Oertel
Rita Cragwall
Isabel Harrison
Seth Reeves
Riley davidson
Dr. Sarno
Peter Konieczny
Dan Reiher
Adrian Marine
Tailsdoll
B Dryad
Andrew Sever
Imperial Pony
Fabrizio Zagonel
Lindorien 
Paul McGee
João Santos
michael coates
Abdallah Al-Ammari
Daniel O'Reilly
Typhoon2401
Deadlock
Gezza The Random Reviewer
Markus Lindström
Michael Corson
blei95
Erik Carlsson
Olaf
Jan Bart Verbist
M Scho
Robin_Col
Kasi
Schwarzer Hai
biohazardgamer
Tarsirrus
James
Laura Jeal
Rhys Little
Ben L
Jackarice26
joshua smyth
Justin McDaid
Twinny Hill
Gina Service
Harrison Tatem-Wyatt
Roberticus1992
Rhys Jackson
DarkLycan 
zemnmez 
Tom Pollard
KingKyumber
George Gremo
James  Ling
Baby Routemaster
Phil Johnston
Matthew Shelby

At the end of the Second World War, Axis borders were redrawn, often as compensation for occupation.

Yugoslavia got this from Italy, Poland got this from Germany, and the USSR gained all of this.

1 nation which had also pushed to gain land from Germany was the Netherlands, which asks to be given all of these lands in 1949.

They didn't get nothing, they were in fact given this tiny bit of land here, most of which they soon sold back to Germany in the 1960s.

But given how badly damaged the Netherlands was by the Second World War, Why weren't they given more land?

So after Germany was defeated, many countries wanted compensation from their occupiers.

The Netherlands was no different and their demands were simple.

Unfortunately for them, the Great Powers had agreed at the Yalta Conference that there would be no financial reparations, mostly because of what had happened last time that Germany was forced to pay such reparations.

And for the Dutch, this meant that the only way that they could get something out of Germany was by annexing land.

The proposals were simple, take as much as we can and kick out all of the Germans who live there.

Internally, the Dutch government had hoped to be given all of this, which included Cologne as well as important historical cities like Aachen and Münster.

There were a few in the government that even pushed for the annexation of lands around Dortmund and Hamburg, but this was seen as unreasonable.

So what happened when they put these ideas to the Allied powers?

They were laughed out of the room by all except France.

This was because France was also pushing for a somewhat dismembered Germany.

The answer was also no and they came back with the third offer of only taking this.

It won't shock you to know that the Allies rejected this as well.

And by Allies, I mean mostly the British.

You see, these lands were in the British zone of occupation and given that East Germany had been divided amongst the Eastern Bloc it had many refugees.

These refugees needed food and housing which was difficult to build.

The Dutch plan to annex these lands and kick out all of the Germans living there would have meant millions more refugees and less places to house them.

Yet for the Dutch, the removal of the Germans from the Netherlands was seen as vital to national security, because it meant that Germany would have less grounds to retake these lands in the future.

The Dutch were pretty angry about this, since it looked like they were going to get nothing which would make the government look pretty weak.

However, the Allies did opt to give some bits of land on the border, here to the Dutch, as a form of placation.

It was occupied in mid-1949 and just short of a decade later the West German government came knocking.

Many in the Dutch government wanted to keep the lands out of principle, but a good working relationship with the new democratic Germany were seen as valuable.

And also, perhaps the Netherlands could use the land to trade for some of the cash that they had wanted previously.

In the end, it was agreed that Germany would pay roughly $80 million for the return of the lands.

The Netherlands kept a tiny bit of land for itself whilst the rest was transferred back to West Germany in 1963.

Meaning, after World War II, the Dutch did get some territorial concessions from Germany, just not very much.

Sky Chappell, Korsho Wolf, Jordan Longley, Adam Stalter, Jerry Lambden, Marcus Arsner, Words About Books Podcast, Rod D.

Martin, Wyan Hockey, Marvin Casale, Spencer Lightfoot, Boogalee Woogalee, Winston Cawood, Captain Psydog, Kimoon Yoon, Gustav Swann, Daniel Tobien, Mrs.

Et Aaron the White, Matthew Shipley, Maggie Patskowski, Alex Schwinn, Corey Turner, Anthony Beckett, Copper Tone, Shuenin, Spinning 3 Plates, The McWhopper and Charles I.


Speaker 0: At the end of the Second World War, Axis borders were redrawn, often as compensation for occupation. Yugoslavia got this from Italy, Poland got this from Germany, and the USSR gained all of this. 1 nation which had also pushed to gain land from Germany was the Netherlands, which asks to be given all of these lands in 1949. As you'll guess, they got very little. They didn't get nothing, they were in fact given this tiny bit of land here, most of which they soon sold back to Germany in the 1960s.

But given how badly damaged the Netherlands was by the Second World War, Why weren't they given more land? So after Germany was defeated, many countries wanted compensation from their occupiers. The Netherlands was no different and their demands were simple. Give us cash, lots of it. Unfortunately for them, the Great Powers had agreed at the Yalta Conference that there would be no financial reparations, mostly because of what had happened last time that Germany was forced to pay such reparations.

And for the Dutch, this meant that the only way that they could get something out of Germany was by annexing land. The proposals were simple, take as much as we can and kick out all of the Germans who live there. Internally, the Dutch government had hoped to be given all of this, which included Cologne as well as important historical cities like Aachen and Münster. There were a few in the government that even pushed for the annexation of lands around Dortmund and Hamburg, but this was seen as unreasonable. So what happened when they put these ideas to the Allied powers?

They were laughed out of the room by all except France. This was because France was also pushing for a somewhat dismembered Germany. As such, plan B. The Dutch reduced their claims to this. The answer was also no and they came back with the third offer of only taking this.

It won't shock you to know that the Allies rejected this as well. And by Allies, I mean mostly the British. You see, these lands were in the British zone of occupation and given that East Germany had been divided amongst the Eastern Bloc it had many refugees. These refugees needed food and housing which was difficult to build. The Dutch plan to annex these lands and kick out all of the Germans living there would have meant millions more refugees and less places to house them.

Yet for the Dutch, the removal of the Germans from the Netherlands was seen as vital to national security, because it meant that Germany would have less grounds to retake these lands in the future. The Dutch were pretty angry about this, since it looked like they were going to get nothing which would make the government look pretty weak. However, the Allies did opt to give some bits of land on the border, here to the Dutch, as a form of placation. It was occupied in mid-1949 and just short of a decade later the West German government came knocking. Many in the Dutch government wanted to keep the lands out of principle, but a good working relationship with the new democratic Germany were seen as valuable.

And also, perhaps the Netherlands could use the land to trade for some of the cash that they had wanted previously. In the end, it was agreed that Germany would pay roughly $80 million for the return of the lands. Well, most of it. The Netherlands kept a tiny bit of land for itself whilst the rest was transferred back to West Germany in 1963. Meaning, after World War II, the Dutch did get some territorial concessions from Germany, just not very much.

Sky Chappell, Korsho Wolf, Jordan Longley, Adam Stalter, Jerry Lambden, Marcus Arsner, Words About Books Podcast, Rod D. Martin, Wyan Hockey, Marvin Casale, Spencer Lightfoot, Boogalee Woogalee, Winston Cawood, Captain Psydog, Kimoon Yoon, Gustav Swann, Daniel Tobien, Mrs. Et Aaron the White, Matthew Shipley, Maggie Patskowski, Alex Schwinn, Corey Turner, Anthony Beckett, Copper Tone, Shuenin, Spinning 3 Plates, The McWhopper and Charles I.

See all History Matters transcripts on Youtube

Why didn't the Netherlands gain territory after World War 2? (Short Animated Documentary)